Customer Reviews:
Excellent product, great pacifiers.
Excellent product. I was heartbroken when I lost it at the store the other day, and my 10-month-old has been looking for it every since, and calls it his “boo-boo.” I love the handy clip, and the fact these items are BPA free.

I second another poster–this is a SOOTHIE/FIRST YEARS PRODUCT. I would imagine Avent pacifiers and clips don’t work with Soothie/First Years pacifiers. Negative reviews due to user error and improper research before buying aren’t the fault of this product.

Had to buy this…
I had to buy this because my hospital started giving my son the soothies in the hospital and now he won’t take another binky. Bummer since I own a bunch of avents…the pacifier holder is also very strange in how it attaches for a newborn without getting in their face.

Great idea, but has one big problem
Soothies are the only pacifiers my son will take and I got tired of chasing them hither and yon so I thought the holder would be a good solution. This binkey holder is a great idea and it’s really cute, but the slot does not create enough friction. My little guy is five months old and he can get the binkey out of the holder fairly easily. I suspect that the problem is that he likes to play with the cute little penguin and twists it all over the place. Additionally, the clip doesn’t always hold very well. If he doesn’t detach the binkey and drop it on the floor or in the nether regions of the car he can pull the clip off his shirt and drop the whole thing.

Terrific item
This item is not only cute but a great idea for holding on to what would otherwise be a tricky little pacifier. A note to the woman who complained that the Soothie Pacifier Attacher doesn’t work with non-Soothie pacifiers: this item is designed specifically for Soothie products and makes no claim that you can use it with any other brand of pacifier. Your rating is based on the fact that you didn’t pay attention to the item description and it should be ignored.

Does not fit to any other pacifier
This pacifier attacher only attaches to same brand pacifier. I’m using Avent pacifiers and this does not attach to it.